Share This Blog
Why Are Diamonds Expensive
If you’ve ever shopped for an engagement ring, you’ve probably asked the big question: Why Are Diamonds Expensive? It’s a fair thing to wonder — diamonds are literally made of carbon, one of the most common elements on Earth. But the diamonds you see in glittering jewelry cases are not “just carbon.” They’re the tiny fraction of stones that survived billions of years under extreme pressure, were found deep underground, and then cut to perfection by highly trained experts.
As someone who sources diamonds daily for clients, I see firsthand how rare high-quality diamonds really are. It’s not about the number of diamonds in the world — it’s the rarity of beautiful diamonds that have excellent cut, great color, and eye-clean clarity. Only a small percentage meet that standard.
Then you factor in:
- The massive cost of mining
- Skill required to cut a rough crystal correctly
- Global demand driven by emotion and tradition
…and you start to understand the real answer to Why Are Diamonds Expensive.
Let’s break it down from every angle — history, economics, science, psychology — and my own hands-on experience.
De Beers Ingenious Advertising
Who Is De Beers?
De Beers didn’t just mine diamonds — they built the idea that a diamond equals love.
Their groundbreaking 1947 line “A Diamond Is Forever” was more than a slogan. It created a connection between diamonds and lifelong commitment. They promoted diamond engagement rings in Hollywood, in magazines, and even in school visits to teach young people that this is what love looks like.
Today, their power over pricing is much smaller. But they permanently shaped the symbolism that still drives demand — and therefore value.
Market Demand
Diamonds are different from most luxury products because demand remains universal. No matter where you go — the U.S., Canada, Europe, India, China — a diamond represents status, strength, and lasting love.
Even when the economy slows, people still propose.
Even when styles change, sparkle doesn’t go out of fashion.
Emotion may not show up on a gemological report — but it’s a huge reason why diamonds are expensive.
Formation of Diamonds
Diamonds start their story 100+ miles beneath Earth’s surface. The process is brutal and beautiful.
Natural Diamonds
- Formed over 1–3 billion years
- Created by intense heat + pressure deep underground
- Forced toward the surface by volcanic eruptions
Only a small portion:
- Survive the journey intact
- Are found by humans
- Meet “gem-quality” standards
That geological miracle is a big reason why are natural diamonds so expensive.
You can learn more in Do Natural Diamonds Hold Value?
Lab Diamonds
Now — what about why are lab grown diamonds so expensive?
Lab diamonds form using:
- HPHT (High Pressure High Temperature)
- CVD (Chemical Vapor Deposition)
They’re:
- Chemically identical
- Physically identical
- Visually identical
And they require:
- Advanced machines
- High energy consumption
- Skilled technicians
But the difference is…
Production can scale forever → prices fall with technology
That’s why lab diamonds are more affordable — and why customers love them.
For a full breakdown, see our guide on 1 Carat Lab Grown Diamond vs Natural Price.
Here’s a quick comparison to show the key differences:
| Feature | Natural Diamonds | Lab Diamonds |
|---|---|---|
| Origin | Formed in Earth over billions of years | Created in a lab within weeks |
| Supply | Finite and declining | Can increase with technology |
| Environmental Impact | Mining footprint varies by region | Lower footprint (energy dependent) |
| Cost | Higher due to rarity | 60–90% less expensive |
| Value Long-Term | Holds premium | Prices continue to drop |
Geographical Sources: Where It Started
Historical Mines
India was once the exclusive diamond source (Golconda)
Brazil later became a major hub
Both are now mostly depleted of top-tier quality.
Contemporary Producers
Modern supply comes from:
- Botswana (high-quality stones + strong social impact)
- Canada (strict environmental standards + full traceability)
- Russia (large reserves)
- Australia (unique colored diamonds like pinks)
Personally, I love sourcing from Canada and Botswana — every diamond’s origin is transparent, ethical, and contributes to real community development.
High Jewellery Store Mark-Ups
Let’s be honest — branding affects price more than most shoppers realize.
Luxury jewelry stores often add 100–300% markups so customers can pay for:
- Celebrity endorsements
- Fifth Avenue storefronts
- Fancy packaging and champagne service
At Fulop Jewelry, I flip that script.
I show clients:
✓ The grading certificate
✓ Comparable wholesale pricing
✓ Where the value truly is
That’s how I regularly help people save 60–80% on virtually identical diamonds — sometimes even better quality.
The Diamond Market
Supply and Demand
Fewer new mines = shrinking long-term supply
Engagement culture = steady global demand
That’s simple economics behind Why Are Diamonds Expensive.
The Industry and Major Players
Rapaport publishes the weekly pricing benchmark
GIA & IGI establish grading standards
Many independent miners and wholesalers compete today
The industry is no longer controlled by a single company — it’s a global network.
Diamond Pricing
Prices are determined by the Four Cs:
Diamond Characteristics
| Characteristic | What It Impacts | Best Value Strategy |
|---|---|---|
Size / Carat |
Visual presence | Buy 0.90–0.98ct instead of 1.00ct to save big with no visual difference |
Color |
Brightness / icy look | In white gold → H color still looks near-colorless |
Clarity |
Visibility of inclusions | VS2 / SI1 eye-clean saves money while still flawless to the viewer |
Cut |
Sparkle + size appearance | Ideal / Excellent cut ONLY — biggest visual upgrade |
Shape |
How large it looks | Ovals, Radiants, Cushions maximize face-up size & value |
My strategy when helping clients choose:
“Prioritize cut → clarity → color → carat.”
Cut is where true beauty comes from — and where many retailers cut corners to advertise a “bigger stone.”
If you want the brightest diamond for your budget, read What Diamond Cut Sparkles The Most?
Alternative Gemstones
Sapphires, rubies, and moissanite are great options — but diamonds still dominate engagements because:
- Maximum durability
- Iconic brilliance
- Deep emotional meaning
Ethical Considerations
“Conflict-free” is the bare minimum.
What matters most today:
- Traceability back to the mine
- Safe and fair labor
- Environmental responsibility
- Community reinvestment
Botswana is the gold standard — diamonds fund schools, hospitals, roads, and national development.
That’s value beyond dollar signs.
Physical and Optical Properties
Durability
Diamonds are the hardest natural material known:
- Scratch-resistant
- Daily-wear friendly
- Heirloom-durable
Light Interaction
A diamond’s sparkle comes from:
- Light reflection (brilliance)
- Light refraction
- Fire (rainbow flashes)
- Scintillation (sparkle during movement)
That visual magic is unmatched — and a major reason why diamonds are expensive.
Why Are They Expensive if They Aren’t Really Rare?
This might be the most important section.
A huge misconception is:
“There are tons of diamonds — so why expensive?”
Here’s the truth:
- Majority of mined diamonds are industrial-grade
- Very few have the beauty needed for fine jewelry
Then add:
- Billions-of-years formation
- High rejection rates
- Skilled cutting with up to 60% rough lost
- Global emotional demand
- Certification costs
- Retail markups (for some)
Here’s a real pricing example I give clients:
| 1.00ct G VVS2 Diamond | Price |
|---|---|
| Natural (GIA) | $4,700 – $6,200 |
| Lab-Grown (IGI) | $600 – $800 |
Both are real diamonds — but only one was carved from the earth billions of years ago.
My philosophy:
“You aren’t buying an investment — you’re buying a legacy.”
Conclusion
So when people ask Why Are Diamonds Expensive, it really comes down to 3 big truths:
- Nature makes quality diamonds rare
Beautiful stones aren’t common — especially in larger sizes - Craftsmanship makes them costly
Mining, cutting, certifying — it’s a long, expensive journey - Emotion makes them priceless
A diamond represents love, commitment, and forever
And that combination — rarity + craftsmanship + meaning — is something no other gemstone fully replaces. Even as prices for lab diamonds drop, natural diamonds remain the ultimate symbol of connection and history.
Whether you choose natural or lab-grown, diamond jewelry should feel exciting — not overwhelming.
Ready to find the perfect diamond? Explore options with our Ring Builder.